Western digital elements vs my passport, which one is better. Terrible average bench the wd my book essentials 1. If it isnt, then the my passport is a more than worthy product for the average user. Looking at 2mb sequential speeds the new wd my passport was. Theres not much to say about the new western digital my book studio 3tb hard drive. The wd elements external hard drive is a rather simple, basic and wellpriced offering. Wd elements, wd my book vs my cloud festplatte gehause offnen wd green 4tb. A blackmagic disk speed test comparison showed the. Quick little speed test on my new wd my book usb 3. While not as fast with sequential transfers as the lacie and seagate drives we. With average sequential readwrite speeds of 150 mbs this version outperforms its predecessor by a whopping 50%.
Hey youtubers, here is the elements desktop 5tb external usb 3. Dec 06, 2019 both the western digital elements and the western digital my passport drive use the 3. Slow transfer speed external drives for pc wd community. The test between these two highlights the difference in form factors.
But all of the desktop drives we tested this year were good. Equipped with social media and cloud storage import, password protection and perfectly paired with wd backup or time machine, my book desktop storage helps keep your files safe. When i transfer data from my hard drive to the external hard disk, the transfer speed is very slow. Wd unveiled today its latest desktop external hard drive the wd my book. Though not as fast as some pricier competition, wds my passport. Reading from the cloud always gives me about 80mbs read speeds and 7075mbs from the attached wd my book. Wd 8tb my book duo desktop raid external hard drive usb. Dualdrive performance equipped with two wd red hdds, my book duo gives you massive capacity with twice the speed. The my book drive is trusted desktop storage designed to complement your personal style with a massive amount of space to store your photos, videos, music and documents. Wd 8tb my book duo desktop raid external hard drive usb 3. I own both only because at the time, one was a better buy than the other when i needed space. Really the speed of transfer and reliability is the same. Wd 12tb my book desktop external hard drive, usb 3.
Millions of people around the world trust their data to my book desktop storage. Wd my book hw recognized by cpu, could manually copy files, but unable to do full backup. Buy wd 10tb my book desktop external hard drive, usb 3. Crystal diskmark, a test of sequential read and write speeds for. The my passport 1tb compared to the wd elements 1tb read performance was 101 mbs. Fast and free shipping free returns cash on delivery available on eligible purchase. The final test i ran on the my passport ultra usbc was a file transfer test. Western digital 5tb my passport portable external hard drive, black wdbpkj0050bbkwesn 4. Sign up for our newsletter and receive a coupon for your next order. Wd discovery can also manage your drive through wd drive utilities. From a 5400 rpm laptop hdd to this wd my book real world transfer speed is averaging 4080 mbs under windows 10. If you are one of the wd elements and wd my passport ultra external hard drive consumers who are currently experiencing a slow transfer speed, slow response or slow boot problem, please read this post carefully. It comes with wd discovery software for wd security to help protect your data and is compatible with apple time. Oct 03, 20 wd recently updated their my book external desktop hard drive line for both the mac and pc audiences.
List of all wd firmware and software available for download. Conclusion overall, wd s new my book is a solid choice for the general consumer looking for a solution to back up a large amount of data, such images of their entire computer and large media files, leveraging a relatively large. External hard drives are more affordable than ever, and our eight favorite drives fit all needs, like a. For performance we did our windows testing on an hp zbook studio x360. It looks quite nice and would go nicely with a mac pro or any.
Slow external hard drives seagate backup plus and wd my book thread starter narial taster. Write performance on the wd my passport was 103 mbs 4% faster, versus 99. Wd elements vs my book the my book is reliable, fast, and less expensive than the other desktop drives we tested, plus it has enough space for your future storage needs and a long, threeyear warranty. We have some benchmarks and the scoop on the western digital 8tb drives found on newer 2016 western digital my book external drives. This isnt a great result which indicates that there are much faster alternatives on the comparison list. How to fix a slow wd external hard drive without losing. Here, the new wd my book recorded a pcmark score of 2552 with a bandwidth of 10. The new drives feature a redesigned enclosure that better aligns with modern design and updates to wds suite of software that comes with each drive. May 24, 2017 the mammoth 8tb capacity on the wd 8tb my book is the largest i have seen to date of this size in terms of dimension, as it measures only 170mm by 140mm. The 8tb version of the western digital my book is a deep well of affordable. With either drive, you need to keep it very close to the device you are working with due to the short length of the cable. Buy wd my book 1tb external hard drive storage usb 3. Slow external hard drives seagate backup plus and wd my book. For a data of 1 gb transfer, it takes around 1520 mins.
Easy to use my passport for mac portable storage is ready to use out of the box so you can start transferring files, saving your memories and backing up right away. The first segment gives the write speed, while the second one gives the read speed for the. Based on 152,446 user benchmarks for the wd black 20 and the black 2016, we rank them both on effective speed and value for money against the best 1,015 hdds. Answered 5 months ago by hihoag2 verified purchase. Model no wdbwlg0080hbk model no wdbbgb0080hbk ell me what drive inside. By combining drive performance, you get up transfer speeds up to 324mbs, so you can transfer a full hd video, or your entire media collection, with ease. We delete comments that violate our policy, which we encourage you to read.
To get started, choose the western digital brand youd like help with. In the aja system test, the drive clocked a write speed of 235. This particular unit used a jmicronbased bridge board with a whitelabel heliumbased drive, which posted performance figures extremely similar to the more premium wd my book series external drive. If you use our links to buy, we may get a commission. Designed to meet wds demanding requirements for durability, shock tolerance, and longterm reliability, we back up pun intended. I once had a wd mybook usb2 and firewire, but the unit was running way to hot. The range of scores 95th 5th percentile for the wd elements 2tb is 31. Festplatten ab 5 tb test ansehen, bestes produkt wahlen. Western digital my book 8tb and my passport 4tb external hdds. Plus, wd has introduced a series of easytouse apps to increase the my book s. Western digital 6tb my book desktop external hard driveusb 3. This is a relatively narrow range which indicates that the wd my book essentials 1. Western digital is one of the top performing companies when it comes to this and their 8tb external my book hard drive that released earlier in the year is a great pick because it is always better to have too much space than not enough.
I did the smart test and it was ok but the quick test failed. The 8tb version of the western digital my book is a deep well of affordable storage for your photos, music, videos, and more. The range of scores 95th 5th percentile for the wd my book 1230 4tb is 44. Western digital elements vs my passport, which one is. The speed test score and results are from an average of all tests. Other than the new design, the drive doesnt have much to elevate it above others. Wd elements vs my passport which is best for your mac. After testing seven hard drives, we found that western digitals 4 tb my. From a 5400 rpm laptop hdd to this wd my book real world transfer speed is averaging 4080 mbs under windows 10 and the same goes up to 5 mbs proof can be seen attached screenshot if this 7200 rpm desktop hdd using usb 3. The blackmagic test will show whether or not the speed of the drive tested will hold up with some common video formats.
Wd attempted to turn portable hard drives into conversation pieces with its 2016 redesign, executed by a highprofile external branding agency. Oct, 2016 here, the new wd my passport pc version recorded a pcmark score of 2,227 and a bandwidth of 8. Pcmark is a test for pc devices so instead of testing the mac formatted my passport which would result in very similar results we tested the recently refreshed wd my book. This becomes a tidious process as it takes very long time to transfer hugh datas. Below average average bench the wd my book 1230 4tb averaged 59. A blackmagic disk speed test comparison showed the read. The my book live unit was put through the standard single user naspt testing that has been used in. Wd recently updated their my book external desktop hard drive line for both the mac and pc audiences. Tips on buying an xbox one hard drive not all external hard drives are created equal, so before you dive in, make sure your potential purchase meets the requirements. Western digital provides data storage solutions, including systems, hdd, flash ssd, memory and personal data solutions to help customers capture and preserve their most valued data. I monitored them over the test and they reached about 5455c and required a fan blowing onto the usb enclosure. Western digitals my book duo series range of sizes from 4tb to 20tb model. Here, the new wd my passport pc version recorded a pcmark score of 2,227 and a bandwidth of 8.
The 4 tb my book is reliable, fast, and cheaper than the competition. The qnap speed test isnt amazing science, but im sure its accurate enough to illustrate the point. The 8 tb version of the western digital my book offers reliability, fast. Answer i can understand your interest in the rpm speed of the wd my book 3tb external usb 3. Oct 11, 2016 wd unveiled today its latest desktop external hard drive the wd my book. All the data copied over ok but ive noticed that the wd has taken a huge hit in speed after the data transfer. This is a relatively wide range which indicates that the wd my book 1230 4tb performs inconsistently under varying real world conditions. Feb 28, 2017 the 8tb version of the western digital my book is a deep well of affordable storage for your photos, music, videos, and more.
Go there for details on competing products and how we tested them. Find low everyday prices and buy online for delivery or instore pickup. Among all the connected, featurerich external hard drives, some folks just want to back up all of their stuff. Wd 10tb my book desktop external hard drive, usb 3. Check out wd my book 1tb external hard drive storage usb 3. Jan 02, 2020 the speed test score and results are from an average of all tests.
If speed is paramount, buy something elseideally an ssd. It seems you have to do this for each usb port or always. The mammoth 8tb capacity on the wd 8tb my book is the largest i have seen to date of this size in terms of dimension, as it measures only 170mm by 140mm. Perhaps is there any way to fix the slow wd external hard drive. Any suggestions on increasing the transfer speed are welcome. Vergleich top 10 im april 2020 festplatte ab 5 tb test. Western digital my book thunderbolt duo 6tb western digitals my book thunderbolt duo is about as big as wds.
854 367 134 1335 615 1164 84 1426 1275 143 801 946 82 1338 1505 424 889 751 834 1600 761 637 1211 684 419 1449 547 1052 110 210 534 1097 778 879 687 165 1358 113 933 913 913 84